How Well Do You Really Know Your Halloween Candy?
There are the candies you immediately look for in a Halloween bowl, the ones you happily trade away, and probably a few you recognize before you even see the name on the wrapper. But how much do you actually know about them?
I have included in this Halloween candy quiz 23 questions about some of the most familiar sweets found in trick-or-treat bags, along with candy history, famous slogans, unusual names, ingredients, movies, wrappers and a few facts that sound almost made up.
ID 25231606 ©Elena Schweitzer | Dreamstime.com
Some questions should be easy if you have spent enough Halloweens digging through a candy haul. Others go beyond simply recognizing a Snickers, Kit Kat or Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. Do you know why Milk Duds are called “Duds”? What the little strip of paper in a Hershey’s Kiss is called? Or which candy became part of movie history thanks to E.T.?
If you want a broader challenge after this one, try my interactive Halloween quiz, with questions covering traditions, folklore, candy, books and movies. For a much bigger trivia round, there are also 200 Halloween trivia questions and answers.
Here, though, it is all about the candy.
Choose an answer for each question and you will immediately find out whether you got it right, along with a short explanation. Your score is calculated automatically at the end.
Ready? Let’s see how close you can get to 23 out of 23.
Question 1 of 23
Before candy corn became a Halloween staple, what farm-themed name was used to market it?
In the late 1800s, the Goelitz Confectionery Company, now Jelly Belly, marketed its version of the kernel-shaped candy as “Chicken Feed,” complete with farm-themed packaging.
Question 2 of 23
What do you find inside a classic REESE’S Peanut Butter Cup?
The classic REESE’S Peanut Butter Cup combines a peanut butter center with milk chocolate. H.B. Reese introduced the cups in 1928.
Question 3 of 23
In E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, which candy does Elliott use to lure E.T. out of hiding?
Elliott uses REESE’S PIECES in the 1982 movie. The appearance became one of the best-known candy product placements in movie history.
Question 4 of 23
Which candy is famous for the slogan “Melts in your mouth, not in your hand”?
The line is the famous M&M’S slogan, referring to the hard candy shell surrounding the chocolate.
Question 5 of 23
Which candy bar combines nougat, caramel and peanuts under milk chocolate?
A classic SNICKERS bar contains nougat topped with caramel and peanuts, all covered in milk chocolate.
Question 6 of 23
Why was the 3 MUSKETEERS bar given its name when it debuted in 1932?
The original 3 MUSKETEERS package contained three candy pieces in three flavors: chocolate, vanilla and strawberry. The product later became the single chocolate-nougat bar familiar today.
Question 7 of 23
What creates the signature layers and crunch inside a classic KIT KAT?
KIT KAT is built around crisp wafer layers covered in chocolate.
Question 8 of 23
Which candy was originally launched in the United Kingdom under the name Opal Fruits?
STARBURST began in Britain as Opal Fruits in 1960. The brand later adopted the STARBURST name used in the United States.
Question 9 of 23
What does the maker of Dum-Dums officially say about its Mystery Flavor?
Spangler says the Dum-Dums Mystery Flavor continuously changes and is not limited to the flavors currently in its regular assortment. Fans are invited to guess what they have unwrapped.
Question 10 of 23
SNICKERS was named after what?
The SNICKERS name is associated with a beloved horse owned by the Mars family. The bar was introduced in 1930.
Question 11 of 23
Where does Laffy Taffy get the jokes that appear on its wrappers?
Laffy Taffy invites consumers to submit jokes for a chance to have them appear on its wrappers.
Question 12 of 23
Which color disappeared from M&M’S bags in 1976 during a public scare over Red Dye No. 2, even though the candy did not use that dye?
Red M&M’S were removed in 1976 amid public concern about red food coloring, even though Red Dye No. 2 was not used in the candies. Red returned to the mix in 1987.
Question 13 of 23
What is the little paper strip sticking out of a HERSHEY’S KISS wrapper officially called?
Hershey calls the parchment-paper strip a “plume.” The printed paper plume was introduced with mechanized KISSES wrapping in 1921.
Question 14 of 23
How did MILK DUDS get the “Duds” part of their name?
According to Hershey, the original manufacturer tried to make perfectly round chocolate-covered caramels but could not, so the imperfectly shaped pieces were called “duds.”
Question 15 of 23
Despite its cosmic-sounding name, what inspired the MILKY WAY candy bar?
Mars says the MILKY WAY bar was created in 1923 to capture the taste of a malted milk shake and was named after a popular malted-milk drink of the era, not the galaxy.
Question 16 of 23
What gas is trapped inside POP ROCKS and released as the candy dissolves, creating those famous little pops?
POP ROCKS contain pressurized carbon dioxide trapped inside the candy. As the sugar dissolves in your mouth, the gas escapes and produces the popping sensation.
Question 17 of 23
During World War II, which candy was included in U.S. G.I. rations as a source of quick energy?
Tootsie’s official history says Tootsie Rolls went into U.S. G.I. rations from 1942 to 1945, providing quick energy for American troops.
Question 18 of 23
Which of these classic sweets appeared first?
Candy corn dates to the 1880s. Tootsie Rolls followed in 1896, HERSHEY’S KISSES in 1907 and SNICKERS in 1930.
Question 19 of 23
Before Hershey introduced a wrapping machine in 1921, how were HERSHEY’S KISSES wrapped?
HERSHEY’S KISSES were foil-wrapped by hand from their introduction in 1907 until mechanized wrapping arrived in 1921.
Question 20 of 23
When the candy we know as KIT KAT debuted in Britain in 1935, what was it called?
The bar launched in Britain in 1935 as Rowntree’s Chocolate Crisp. The KIT KAT name was added later.
Question 21 of 23
A Sour Apple Dum-Dum lists which acid alongside citric acid in its ingredients?
Spangler lists both citric acid and malic acid in Sour Apple Dum-Dums. Malic acid also occurs naturally in fruits such as apples and contributes tartness.
Question 22 of 23
According to Instacart’s September 2026 Halloween report, based on 2025 orders, which candy ranked No. 1 in the U.S. by ounces sold?
Instacart’s 2026 Halloween report, analyzing 2025 orders, ranked REESE’S Peanut Butter Cups No. 1 by ounces sold. They were also the top seller in 40 of the 50 states plus Washington, D.C.
Question 23 of 23
FINAL QUESTION: Which Hershey candy bar reportedly got its name after Milton Hershey misheard someone saying, “That’s a good bar”?
Hershey’s history says someone in the product-development lab remarked, “That’s a good bar.” Milton Hershey thought the person had said “Mister Goodbar,” and the name stuck.
Your result
You got 0 out of 23
Your candy bag still has a few mysteries hiding in it. You knew some of the classics, but Halloween candy has more strange history than you expected. Try again and see how many you remember.
You know your Halloween candy staples and picked up some of the stranger facts too. A few wrappers, origins and candy secrets kept you from the top.
Strong score. You know what is inside the classics, recognize the famous names and slogans, and even survived some surprisingly tricky candy history.
You would be very hard to beat at a Halloween candy trivia table. Very few wrappers, candy-bar origins or sweet surprises got past you.
That is an exceptional score. From Chicken Feed and candy plumes to malted milk and Mystery Flavor, you know far more about the Halloween candy bowl than most people do. Share your score and challenge someone to beat it.
How Did You Do on the Halloween Candy Quiz?
Some of those were easy. If you have ever eaten a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup or broken apart a Kit Kat, you had a few points waiting for you. But candy gets surprisingly strange once you start looking beyond what is printed on the front of the wrapper.
A candy once marketed as Chicken Feed became a Halloween classic. A famous chocolate bar took its name from a family horse. Milk Duds owe their name to a manufacturing problem, while the tiny paper strip sticking out of a Hershey’s Kiss has its own official name. Even the familiar candies we have seen for years can hide some very odd stories.
If those were your favorite questions, I have 75 Halloween facts covering candy as well as costumes, pumpkins, trick-or-treating, folklore and the history behind familiar Halloween traditions.
For another game you can play with family or friends, these Halloween Would You Rather questions have 150 funny, spooky, creepy and difficult choices. Movie fans can test themselves with Halloween movie trivia instead.
And Halloween does not have to be the end of the trivia season. You can continue with my November trivia questions or jump straight to the interactive Thanksgiving trivia quiz.
How many of the 23 Halloween candy questions did you get right? Share your score with someone who always claims to know the best candy in the bowl and see if they can beat you.
I got ___/23 on the Halloween Candy Quiz. Can you beat my score?
Halloween Candy Quiz: Frequently Asked Questions
What is included in this Halloween candy quiz?
The quiz has 23 multiple-choice questions covering popular Halloween candy, chocolate bars, candy ingredients, brand history, famous slogans, unusual candy names, wrappers, pop culture and other candy facts. Each question has one correct answer and a short explanation.
How many questions are in the Halloween candy quiz?
There are 23 questions. The quiz starts with several familiar candies and includes harder questions about candy history and facts as you continue.
Is this Halloween candy quiz suitable for a party or family game?
Yes. You can take the interactive quiz individually or use the questions as a Halloween party game with family and friends. The questions focus on candy knowledge rather than frightening or graphic Halloween topics.
What candies are included in the quiz?
The questions include well-known candies and brands such as Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Snickers, M&M’s, Kit Kat, 3 Musketeers, Starburst, Dum-Dums, Laffy Taffy, Hershey’s Kisses, Milk Duds, Milky Way, Pop Rocks, Tootsie Rolls and candy corn.
Where can I find more Halloween trivia questions?
For a wider range of Halloween topics, try my 200 Halloween trivia questions. They cover Halloween history, traditions, candy, superstitions and celebrations, while the 20-question interactive Halloween quiz gives you another scored challenge.
More amazing articles for you:
150 European History Trivia Questions and Answers: Easy to Expert - Can You Reach the Final Round?
A guide to Haldwani, Uttarakhand, India
Atlanta City Guide: Tips for Spending a Weekend in Atlanta with the Kids
200 2010s Trivia Questions and Answers - Easy to Hard. How Many Can You Get Right?
Going to Italy? These 75+ Words and Phrases Could Make Your Trip Much Easier
These Places Don’t Feel Like December at All
What to pack for a trip to Europe in spring: travel essentials
Travelling with a dog by car: tips for a paw-some experience
Violeta-Loredana Pascal is a communications expert, business mentor, and the founder of Earth’s Attractions and PRwave INTERNATIONAL. A pioneer in the Romanian digital PR landscape since 2005, she holds a degree in Communication and Social Sciences from SNSPA Bucharest. Violeta is a senior trainer at AcademiadeAfaceri.ro, where she leverages over 20 years of experience to teach professional courses in PR strategy and workplace productivity. By blending high-level business consulting with a passion for holistic travel and wellness, she empowers solopreneurs to overcome procrastination, build profitable brands, and design a life of purposeful adventure.
